data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/af246/af2464e1800934c52927631b1a4b3bbc08b90594" alt="twitconnect"
I inspected the error_log and found the culprit to be the Twitconnect plugin not being able to redeclare one of its classes.
I didn't change anything, so I'm not sure why it suddenly decided to have an issue.
I deleted the Twitconnect directory from /wp-content/plugins and that fixed it.